‘Worst Apple launch ever’? HomeView issues pile up as early adopters slam new smart hub

Posted

Macworld

HomeView went on sale just three days ago, but the product has already been deluged with complaints. While the hardware has been well received, some owners have reported a variety of software issues across multiple threads on multiple forums. These cover areas as diverse as Music, Photos, device setup, Siri performance and screen auto-brightness.

On the MacRumors forums, we found four separate threads discussing HomeView’s shortcomings, with some 170 posts at the time of writing. The shortest of these focuses on Siri and the Music app, complaining that the device “won’t stop music that is playing,” advising the user that something has gone wrong and to try again later, and that it won’t restart music that’s been paused. A second thread reports that Siri simply won’t play music. One respondent to this adds the further complication: “when I ask it to play music, continue music, skip tracks etc, despite talking very clearly to the HomeView (Siri clearly on screen listening) it does the action on my iPhone.”

Another thread complains that Siri on the HomeView can’t set timers. (This might seem somewhat trivial, but it’s actually a key function because the HomeView has been marketed as a useful tool in the kitchen.) Many other forum users confirm they’ve also experienced this, and the thread author claims this is backed up by a call to Apple support.

The longest thread on that forum has a total of 129 posts at present, and begins with a broad complaint about “problem after problem.”

“I have two HomeViews, and they simply don’t work properly,” the author begins with obvious exasperation. “One unit spent half of yesterday saying it was downloading Siri. Once Siri sort of started working, it wouldn’t do basic things like set timers because ‘the software update on this device doesn’t support that.’ The Photos app on the main screen shows a photo from my phone and advertises a collection of favorites, yet when I tap it, the HomeView says Photos aren’t supported on this device. My second HomeView had all these exact same problems.

“This morning, the first one suddenly works for setting timers, though it still won’t do anything with Photos. The second one showed the Siri bubble this morning, but wouldn’t even respond to anything I asked. A reboot got Siri responding again, still without timer support. I rebooted it again, and now it won’t even show the Siri bubble, just repeating ‘downloading Siri’ (again) any time I use the wake word.”

Foundry

Reports of issues aren’t by any means confined to the MacRumors forums. On Reddit we discovered another four threads with similar complaints. We’ve seen widgets forgetting user preferences and needing to be reset; auto-brightness failing to do anything until you turn it off and on again; music libraries and playlists being difficult to access; and the device refusing to pair with an iPhone, resulting in failed setup.

In most of those cases, to avoid boring the reader, I’ve cherrypicked a single complaint out of several that are discussed. But there are hundreds of complaints about dozens of separate issues. And that’s even without the usual contributions of Apple Support Community, a frequent destination for users reporting issues of this nature which was conveniently shuttered by Apple last week.

To an extent it’s to be expected that a brand-new product will have software problems in the first few days after launch; when the product is a company’s first attempt at a new market, as is the case here, we should expect even more of them. Many of the issues, we would hope, will be solved by software updates; and in some of the threads you’ll see positive outcomes when users received help that actually worked. (One was advised that the problem might be caused by them running a beta version of iOS. When they factory-reset the device, the problem went away.) This isn’t totally surprising, nor will all of these problems be an issue in the medium and long term.

Nevertheless, even by the standards of new tech products, this is a lot of complaints covering a lot of ground. Apple didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment, but the company needs to address this as a matter of urgency.

Smart Home